Psychology World — home
Blog

Self-determination theory: the motivation theory that isn't a pyramid

Self-determination theory names three basic needs — autonomy, competence, relatedness — pursued together, not stacked in a hierarchy like Maslow's.

Motivation12 min read
By Psychology World

Updated 22 October 2026

Self-determination theory (SDT) is a theory of human motivation developed by the psychologists Edward Deci and Richard Ryan. It proposes that people have three innate psychological needs, autonomy, competence and relatedness. When social conditions support those needs, people become more self-motivated and psychologically healthier; when conditions thwart them, motivation and well-being diminish. Two features set the theory apart. It asks what kind of motivation a person has, not only how much. And it treats the three needs as a set that is required together, with no ranking between them, which is the main difference from Maslow's hierarchy.

  • Ryan and Deci built the theory at the University of Rochester from the 1970s and 1980s. The standard summary is their 2000 paper in American Psychologist.
  • The three needs are autonomy (feeling that you choose your behaviour), competence (feeling effective in the activity) and relatedness (feeling connected to others).
  • Ryan and Deci call the needs essential nutriments: all three are required, and the 2000 paper ranks none above another.
  • SDT is a framework of six mini-theories, not a single hypothesis.
  • A 2022 review of 60 meta-analyses, led by Ryan, reports support for much of the theory and names gaps in the evidence.

The three basic psychological needs

SDT defines each need by an experience, not by a skill or a trait. The second column follows APA's summary of the theory. The last two list conditions that Ryan and Deci's 2000 paper links to supporting or undermining each need.

The three needs, and the conditions Ryan and Deci (2000) link to each.
NeedThe experienceConditions that support itConditions that undermine it
AutonomyFeeling that you choose your behaviour rather than being controlled or compelledChoice, acknowledgment of feelings, opportunities for self-directionThreats, deadlines, directives, pressured evaluations, imposed goals, expected tangible rewards for doing the task
CompetenceFeeling that you can be effective in the activityOptimal challenges, feedback that builds a sense of effectiveness, freedom from demeaning evaluationsNegative performance feedback, demeaning evaluations, challenges that are not optimal
RelatednessFeeling connected to others and that you belongA sense of security and connection with the people in the settingBeing ignored by an adult, or meeting coldness from a teacher

Autonomy: volition, not independence

Autonomy is the easiest of the three to misread. In everyday speech it suggests independence, doing things alone and answering to no one. In SDT it is narrower. Ryan and Deci write that autonomy "refers not to being independent, detached, or selfish but rather to the feeling of volition that can accompany any act" (2000, p. 74). Someone can follow a teacher's advice or a family's expectation autonomously, if they endorse it. The paper reports Korean and US samples in which autonomy related more positively to collectivistic than to individualistic attitudes, and teenagers whose closeness to parents went with more autonomy, not less. So autonomy and relatedness are not rivals.

Competence: feeling effective is not enough alone

Competence is the feeling that you can be effective in the activity. Cognitive evaluation theory, as the 2000 paper summarises it, adds a condition: feelings of competence do not raise intrinsic motivation unless they come with a sense of autonomy (p. 70). Ryan and Deci also report that people whose motivation is self-endorsed show more interest, excitement and confidence than people who are externally controlled, even at the same level of perceived competence or self-efficacy (p. 69). Our article on self-esteem vs self-efficacy covers the second term.

Relatedness: connection as a secure base

Relatedness is the need to feel belonging and connectedness with others. The 2000 paper cites two findings. Children working on an interesting task beside an adult stranger who ignored them showed very low intrinsic motivation, and so did students who saw their teachers as cold and uncaring. The paper is more tentative here than for the other two needs: links between intrinsic motivation and autonomy and competence "have been clearly demonstrated", while "some work suggests" that relatedness matters too, "at least in a distal sense". Many intrinsically motivated activities are done happily alone, so relatedness may work as a secure base rather than as company in the room.

What makes a need "basic"

Everyday speech lets need and want blur. SDT does not. In Ryan and Deci's definition, a basic need "is an energizing state that, if satisfied, conduces toward health and well-being but, if not satisfied, contributes to pathology and ill-being" (2000, p. 74). Deci and Ryan say in a second paper from the same year that Henry Murray's long list of needs, which included abasement and acquisitiveness, describes motives that may energise action but are not needs in this sense.

Two consequences follow. The first is that the needs come as a set. The 2000 paper puts it this way:

Specifying psychological needs as essential nutriments implies that individuals cannot thrive without satisfying all of them, any more than people can thrive with water but not food.
— Ryan and Deci, 2000, p. 75

A setting that offers competence but no relatedness should therefore leave well-being impoverished, the paper adds, and a setting that pits the needs against each other, as when a child must give up autonomy to feel loved, sets up conditions for alienation.

The second consequence is that SDT measures satisfaction, not strength. The research tradition built on Murray and McClelland measures how strongly people differ in needs such as achievement, power and affiliation. Because SDT treats its three needs as universal, Deci and Ryan write that their research focuses instead on how far people experience those needs as satisfied.

Where the theory comes from, and its six parts

In the 1970s and 1980s, Ryan and Deci, then both at the University of Rochester, began working out a theory that differed from the behaviourist accounts of the time, which revolved around reinforcement. Ryan told APA they started instead from "people's inherent propensities to learn and to be curious". Their raw material was the reward experiments. As the 2000 paper describes it, Deci (1975) read the finding that extrinsic rewards can undermine intrinsic motivation as rewards shifting the perceived cause of the behaviour outside the person, which is a loss of autonomy. Our article on intrinsic vs extrinsic motivation covers those experiments and the continuum of extrinsic motivation in detail.

Two sub-theories came first, in Deci and Ryan's 1985 book. Cognitive evaluation theory deals with how social contexts affect intrinsic motivation. Organismic integration theory deals with the forms of extrinsic motivation, and the continuum from external to integrated regulation comes from it. Amotivation, "the state of lacking the intention to act", sits beside that continuum. The 2000 paper traces it partly to not expecting an activity to yield a desired outcome, citing Seligman, which is the territory of learned helplessness.

APA's 2025 summary describes SDT today as a metatheory made of six smaller sub-theories.

The six mini-theories of self-determination theory, as APA summarises them.
Mini-theoryWhat it addresses
Cognitive evaluation theoryHow rewards, interpersonal controls and ego-involvements affect intrinsic motivation
Organismic integration theoryThe forms of extrinsic motivation, and their causes and consequences
Causality orientations theoryIndividual differences in how people orient toward environments
Basic psychological needs theoryThe evolved psychological needs and how they relate to health and well-being
Goal contents theoryHow intrinsic and extrinsic goals affect motivation and wellness
Relationships motivation theoryHow relatedness develops and is maintained

Self-determination theory vs Maslow's hierarchy

A common comparison is between SDT and Maslow's hierarchy of needs. The two are relatives on one point: Deci and Ryan say their concept of needs is in some ways closer to theories that treat psychological needs as innate, and they name Kohut and Maslow, than to the Murray and McClelland tradition, which treats needs as learned. The differences are in the list, the order and what happens when a need goes unmet.

Maslow's hierarchy and self-determination theory on three points.
Point of comparisonMaslow's hierarchy (1943)Self-determination theory
The needsFive levels: physiological, safety, love and belonging, esteem, self-actualizationThree psychological needs: autonomy, competence, relatedness
OrderNeeds dominate in a rough order of prepotency, which Maslow himself said was not rigidNone: the needs are required together
When a need goes unmetAn unsatisfied lower need dominates behaviour until it is fairly well gratifiedThwarting harms motivation and well-being, but people may build defences and need substitutes instead of pressing harder

The clean difference is the order. The 2000 paper gives the three needs no ranking and says all must be satisfied across the life span, as the water-and-food comparison above implies. Maslow's own text was looser than the pyramid, which he did not draw, so the sharper contrast is between SDT and the popular staircase. Our article on Maslow's hierarchy of needs covers what the studies found about the order.

A second contrast, deficit against growth, needs care. Deci and Ryan draw it against drive theories, whose needs are physiological deficits, and write that in SDT "the set point is growth-oriented activity". Maslow also had a growth need, self-actualization, so that line does not run between the two theories. What the authors stress instead is that people do not act in order to meet a need. Children play because play interests them, not to feel competent, and need satisfaction is what lets that play go well.

One study tested the list directly. Sheldon, Elliot, Kim and Kasser (2001) asked people to describe their most satisfying events, then rated how salient each of ten candidate needs was within them. Autonomy, competence and relatedness were consistently among the top four, in US and South Korean samples. Self-esteem also mattered, while self-actualization or meaning, physical thriving, popularity or influence, and money-luxury mattered less. That measures what made events satisfying, not whether needs must be met in sequence, but the authors discuss it as bearing on hierarchical theories of need. Self-esteem's showing is one reason to treat three as the theory's answer rather than a settled count.

What the evidence shows, and where it is thin

The 2000 paper draws on experiments that change a social condition, such as feedback, rewards or choice; field studies in settings such as schools and families; and studies that link people's reports of need satisfaction to well-being. The last kind is correlational, and the paper words it that way: within specific domains, need satisfaction is "correlated with improved well-being". Two examples it reports:

  • Work: employees' satisfaction of the needs for autonomy, competence and relatedness predicted their performance and well-being at work, in a study the paper cites as an unpublished manuscript.
  • Daily life: within the same person, day-to-day swings in satisfaction of autonomy and competence predicted swings in mood, vitality, physical symptoms and self-esteem. The paper calls comparing each person with their own average a more compelling way to show the link.

The broader check is a 2022 meta-review in Psychological Bulletin. Its team, led by Richard Ryan, identified 60 meta-analyses and reported support for the validity of SDT's taxonomy of motivation and for its hypotheses about need satisfaction and need frustration, and strong support for the theory's relevance to organisations, health care, parenting and education. It also names identifiable gaps in the meta-analytic literature. Because Ryan is one of the theory's two developers, this is a review by the theory's authors, not an outside audit, and APA's summary notes that researchers still debate some of the details.

Later work puts more weight on need frustration: Vansteenkiste and Ryan (2013) describe need satisfaction as fostering well-being and later resilience, and need frustration as evoking ill-being and a vulnerability to defensiveness and psychopathology.

Using the needs in school and when you study

In education, APA's summary gives concrete examples. Autonomy might mean giving students more choice in what they study or how they show mastery, and well-designed group work or peer feedback can speak to relatedness. It quotes Chantal Levesque-Bristol of Purdue saying that higher education usually concentrates on competence and mastery and forgets the other two needs. A laboratory experiment the 2000 paper describes, by Deci and colleagues, found that a meaningful rationale for an uninteresting behaviour, delivered with support for autonomy and relatedness, promoted internalisation, while controlling contexts produced less of it.

SDT is not a study method, and nothing in it says a particular tool meets the three needs. As an observation rather than a finding, the three needs can serve as a checklist for a study routine. Choosing what goes on your list is a choice, one of the conditions linked to autonomy, and seeing your recall improve speaks to competence. Relatedness is the weakest fit for solo study, and the 2000 paper itself notes that many intrinsically motivated activities are done alone. In Psychology World you can save terms to a named list and drill that list with flashcards, multiple-choice questions once it has four or more words, or typing. Our guide to memorising psychology terminology covers the study side.

Frequently asked questions

Is self-determination theory the same as intrinsic motivation?

No. Intrinsic motivation, doing an activity for its inherent satisfaction, is the subject of one of SDT's six mini-theories, cognitive evaluation theory. The others cover the forms of extrinsic motivation, individual differences, the basic needs, goals and relationships.

Are the three needs the same in every culture?

SDT's claim is that the needs are universal but that their relative salience, the routes to satisfying them and the way they are expressed differ between cultures (Ryan and Deci, 2000). The 2000 paper reports that findings on life goals replicated in a Russian sample, and Sheldon and colleagues found the same ranking of needs in US and South Korean samples. That is encouraging, but it covers a few countries, not all cultures.

Does self-determination theory say rewards are bad?

No, but it says which rewards are risky. The 2000 paper reports a meta-analysis by Deci, Koestner and Ryan (1999) finding that expected tangible rewards made contingent on task performance reliably undermined intrinsic motivation, and says threats, deadlines and pressured evaluations do too, because they move the cause of the behaviour outside the person. The theory also holds that extrinsic motivation can become self-endorsed, so a reason that began outside a person can end up as their own.

Sources

  1. 1.Ryan, R. M., & Deci, E. L. (2000). Self-determination theory and the facilitation of intrinsic motivation, social development, and well-being. American Psychologist, 55(1), 68-78.
  2. 2.Deci, E. L., & Ryan, R. M. (2000). The "what" and "why" of goal pursuits: Human needs and the self-determination of behavior. Psychological Inquiry, 11(4), 227-268.
  3. 3.Weir, K. (2025, March 2). Self-determination theory: A quarter century of human motivation research. American Psychological Association.
  4. 4.Ryan, R. M., Duineveld, J. J., Di Domenico, S. I., Ryan, W. S., Steward, B. A., & Bradshaw, E. L. (2022). We know this much is (meta-analytically) true: A meta-review of meta-analytic findings evaluating self-determination theory. Psychological Bulletin, 148(11-12), 813-842.
  5. 5.Sheldon, K. M., Elliot, A. J., Kim, Y., & Kasser, T. (2001). What is satisfying about satisfying events? Testing 10 candidate psychological needs. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 80(2), 325-339.
  6. 6.Vansteenkiste, M., & Ryan, R. M. (2013). On psychological growth and vulnerability: Basic psychological need satisfaction and need frustration as a unifying principle. Journal of Psychotherapy Integration, 23(3), 263-280.

Look the terms up yourself

18,000+ psychology and psychotherapy terms in English and German, on iPhone, iPad, Mac and Apple Vision.

See how Psychology World works
All posts