Psychology World — home
Blog

The Hawthorne effect: why being watched changes behavior, and what the factory studies really showed

Why people do better when watched: the Hawthorne factory studies, what they found, why scholars doubt them, and how researchers adjust.

Research methods9 min read
By Psychology World

People often perform better when they know someone is studying them. That change has a name from factory research: the Hawthorne effect. In studies at Western Electric's Hawthorne Works from 1924 to the early 1930s, output rose whenever researchers paid attention to workers. It rose whatever else the researchers changed. Later reanalyses found the original evidence weaker than the legend. Controlled studies still find small effects of being studied, so researchers design around them.

  • The Hawthorne effect means behavior changes because a person knows they are observed, not because of the tested change.
  • Four factory studies form the story: lighting tests, a relay assembly room, worker interviews, and a bank wiring room.
  • The legend says attention raised output. The record is messier: one study held output down, and pay and rest changed too.
  • A 2014 review of 19 studies found real but uneven effects of being studied, with no clear size.
  • Use one test on any example. If only observation changed, suspect the Hawthorne effect.

What the Hawthorne effect is

The Hawthorne effect is a change in behavior that comes from awareness of being observed. A worker speeds up because researchers watch. A patient washes hands more when an observer stands nearby. The tested condition did not cause the change. Being studied caused it.

The term is younger than the studies. John R. P. French coined it in 1953, and sociologist Henry A. Landsberger spread it with his 1958 book Hawthorne Revisited (Simply Psychology (n.d.). Hawthorne Effect in Psychology: Experimental Studies.). The name points to the Hawthorne Works, a Western Electric telephone plant in Cicero, near Chicago, where the research ran from 1924 to the early 1930s (Wikipedia contributors (n.d.). Hawthorne effect.).

How solid is the effect today? A 2014 systematic review gathered 19 studies designed to test it. Most found some sign that taking part in research changes behavior. The studies differed so much that the authors could say little secure about when it works, how it works, or how large it is (McCambridge, J., Witton, J., and Elbourne, D. R. (2014). Systematic review of the Hawthorne effect.). Treat the effect as real enough to control and too uneven to predict.

The four factory studies

Popular versions compress the story into one lighting test. The program held four separate studies over about nine years. Each one matters, because the last one points the other way.

The illumination tests, 1924-1927

Researchers tested whether light levels changed output in workers who assembled electrical relays. They ran the test in two rooms and varied the lighting. Output rose both when light improved and when it fell to a level that made work hard to see. The researchers concluded that light did not drive the change and that some other variable did (Wikipedia contributors (n.d.). Hawthorne effect.). That other variable became the search that defined the rest of the program.

The relay assembly test room, from 1927

A small group of women who assembled telephone relays moved to a separate room. There the researchers varied rest breaks, the length of the workday, and pay methods. Output rose across most changes. Elton Mayo and his Harvard colleagues read the rise as the effect of attention and team spirit. When the special attention faded, the gains faded too (Simply Psychology (n.d.). Hawthorne Effect in Psychology: Experimental Studies.). Roethlisberger and Dickson, two members of the research team, published the full account in 1939 in Management and the Worker, and revisited the lessons in 1966 (Harvard Business School Library (n.d.). The Hawthorne Effect.).

The interviews, 1928-1930

The program then interviewed tens of thousands of workers, about 20,000 in total. Direct questions about supervision worked poorly, so interviewers switched to listening. The mere fact of being heard seemed to lift morale. The lesson for management outlasted the numbers: workers respond to attention from their supervisors, not only to pay and conditions (Wikipedia contributors (n.d.). Hawthorne effect.).

The bank wiring room, 1931-1932

Fourteen men who wired telephone switching equipment worked under observation while researchers tested pay incentives and small-group effects. Output did not rise. It fell. The men capped their output because they feared that higher output would bring lower piece rates. Group pressure set the norm, and attention did not break it (Wikipedia contributors (n.d.). Hawthorne effect.). Any account that says attention always raises output skips this room.

Why scholars doubt the original story

The legend took hold fast: attention raises productivity. The record supports a weaker claim. Five problems carry most of the doubt.

First, the relay data look thinner on reanalysis. Economist S. R. G. Jones re-examined the relay experiments and published the result in 1992 (Wikipedia contributors (n.d.). Hawthorne effect.). His reanalysis left the dramatic pattern largely absent from the numbers (Simply Psychology (n.d.). Hawthorne Effect in Psychology: Experimental Studies.).

Second, the lighting tests were not true experiments by modern rules. Economists Steven Levitt and John A. List spent years hunting the original base data before they found it. List still holds that the effect is genuine, but the search showed how loose the early design was (Wikipedia contributors (n.d.). Hawthorne effect.).

Third, several changes ran together with attention. Rest breaks, shorter days, different pay, feedback on output, and the novelty of selection all changed at once. Workers interviewed decades later also reported clearly better pay (Greenwood, Bolton, and Greenwood, 1983). Any one of these could lift output without any observation effect (Wikipedia contributors (n.d.). Hawthorne effect.).

Fourth, learning confounds the story. H. M. Parsons argued that the relay gains fit practice and feedback: people improve at a task they repeat with knowledge of results. B. L. Pitcher made the statistical case for a learning hypothesis in 1981 (McCambridge, J., Witton, J., and Elbourne, D. R. (2014). Systematic review of the Hawthorne effect.).

Fifth, the bank wiring result contradicts the simple moral. If attention raised output, the observed men should have produced more. They produced less, because group norms and pay fears weighed more than the observers (Simply Psychology (n.d.). Hawthorne Effect in Psychology: Experimental Studies.). Wickstrom and Bendix concluded in 2000 that the supposed effect is ambiguous and disputable (Wikipedia contributors (n.d.). Hawthorne effect.).

None of this kills the concept. It demotes the factory story from proof to warning. The human relations movement still grew from these studies, and the term still names a real design problem (Harvard Business School Library (n.d.). The Hawthorne Effect.).

What modern studies find

Modern work tests research participation directly instead of retelling the factory story. The results are modest and concrete.

Hand hygiene gives the cleanest numbers. When medical staff knew observers watched, hand-washing compliance ran 55 percent higher than when they did not (Eckmanns, 2006). A later study counted five hand hygiene events per patient per hour under observation against two without it, and attributed 61 percent of the variation to observation itself (Hagel and colleagues, 2015). Trial follow-up shows the same pattern: dementia patients with intensive assessment visits did better than patients with minimal follow-up in a trial of Ginkgo biloba (McCarney and colleagues, 2007). Each example comes from the bias catalogue that collects them (Catalog of Bias Collaboration (n.d.). Hawthorne effect.).

Observation can also be the treatment on purpose. Weight-loss programs ask clients to keep a food diary because recording meals changes eating. The measurement is the intervention (Catalog of Bias Collaboration (n.d.). Hawthorne effect.). Promoters use the same logic in public: signs that announce hand-washing checks, or visible cameras above roads, steer behavior by announcing observation (Nielsen Norman Group (2023). The Hawthorne Effect or Observer Bias in User Research.).

Terms people mix up

Four related terms cause most of the confusion. The table sorts them by mechanism.

What each term means, and how it differs from the Hawthorne effect.
TermWhat happensExample
Hawthorne effectBehavior changes because a person knows they are studiedFactory output rises under researchers' eyes
Demand characteristicsBehavior changes because a participant guesses the hypothesis and reacts to itA student spots the tested behavior and plays along
Observer effectOften used as another name for the Hawthorne effect in user research; strictly, any disturbance caused by measuringAn observer with a clipboard changes a test session
Placebo effectImprovement comes from expecting an inactive treatment to work, not from being observedA sugar pill eases pain through belief

A fifth confusion deserves one line. The Pygmalion effect, where a teacher's expectations lift student scores, is a case of the self-fulfilling prophecy, not of being studied. Expectation drives it. Observation does not.

How researchers adjust for it

No method removes the problem fully, but several shrink it. Hidden or unobtrusive observation helps, though even knowing that one takes part in a study may still change behavior (Persell, 2016) (Catalog of Bias Collaboration (n.d.). Hawthorne effect.). User researchers add three habits: build rapport so participants act naturally, design tasks that feel like real work, and spend enough time with participants for the novelty of being watched to wear off (Nielsen Norman Group (2023). The Hawthorne Effect or Observer Bias in User Research.).

Equal treatment of groups matters too. If observers watch the treatment group more closely than the control group, the extra attention alone can fake a treatment effect. Both groups need the same observation schedule (Catalog of Bias Collaboration (n.d.). Hawthorne effect.). In short, the Hawthorne effect threatens the validity of a study: without these controls, no one knows whether the treatment or the watching caused the result.

How to remember it for exams

Turn the story into a set you can drill. Save Hawthorne, demand characteristics, and observer bias to a bookmark list such as Research methods. Then drill that list with the Question game, which needs at least four words in the list. Ask of each term: did behavior change because someone watched, because someone guessed, or because someone expected. Short repeated sessions beat one long reread. A daily word keeps the set alive between sessions.

Frequently asked questions

What is the Hawthorne effect in simple terms?

It is the change in behavior that comes from knowing you are observed. People work faster, follow rules better, or answer more carefully while someone studies them, then drift back when the watching stops.

What are the four stages of the Hawthorne experiment?

They are four studies, not stages. Lighting tests ran from 1924 to 1927, a relay assembly room ran from 1927, mass interviews ran from 1928 to 1930, and a bank wiring observation room ran in 1931 and 1932. Each tested a different idea about work and attention.

Is the Hawthorne effect real?

Partly. The factory legend overstates the proof, and reanalyses weakened it. But a 2014 review of 19 designed studies found that taking part in research does change behavior in at least some settings. Treat it as a real risk with unknown size, not as a law.

How is it different from demand characteristics?

The Hawthorne effect comes from being observed. Demand characteristics come from guessing the hypothesis behind the study. A participant can show both at once, but the triggers differ: eyes versus clues.

How do researchers reduce it?

They observe unobtrusively, build rapport, use natural tasks, spend more time with participants, and watch every group equally. None of these removes the effect fully, because the knowledge of taking part can itself change behavior.

Sources

  1. 1.McCambridge, J., Witton, J., and Elbourne, D. R. (2014). Systematic review of the Hawthorne effect: New concepts are needed to study research participation effects. Journal of Clinical Epidemiology.
  2. 2.Wikipedia contributors (n.d.). Hawthorne effect.
  3. 3.Simply Psychology (n.d.). Hawthorne Effect in Psychology: Experimental Studies.
  4. 4.Catalog of Bias Collaboration (n.d.). Hawthorne effect.
  5. 5.Nielsen Norman Group (2023). The Hawthorne Effect or Observer Bias in User Research.
  6. 6.Harvard Business School Library (n.d.). The Hawthorne Effect.

Look the terms up yourself

18,000+ psychology and psychotherapy terms in English and German, on iPhone, iPad, Mac and Apple Vision.

See how Psychology World works
All posts