Attribution theory asks why a behavior happened. It answers with a cause inside the person or outside in the situation. Fritz Heider named the question in 1958. Later models by Jones and Davis, Kelley and Weiner gave rules for when each answer fits.
- Internal attribution points to a trait, ability or effort.
- External attribution points to a task, luck or setting.
- Jones and Davis read single acts. Kelley reads repeated acts.
- Weiner adds stability and control, which shape feeling and effort.
- Real judges under-use consensus and over-read traits.
What attribution means
An attribution is a cause you assign to a behavior. You see an act. You link it to a trait or to a setting. The link guides what you expect next.
Internal attribution assigns the cause to the person. A student passes because she worked hard. A driver cuts you off because he is rude.
External attribution assigns the cause to the setting. A student fails because the test was unfair. A driver cuts you off because the lane markings were unclear.
The same act can take both readings. The theory does not ask which reading feels right. It asks which rule supports it.
Heider and the naive psychologist
Fritz Heider published The Psychology of Interpersonal Relations in 1958. He argued that ordinary people act as naive psychologists. They watch acts and infer hidden causes. They prefer stable causes because stable causes make the world predictable.
Heider kept two groups of causes. Internal causes sit in the person, such as ability and effort. External causes sit in the world, such as task difficulty. Later work added luck as a fourth cause.
Heider and Marianne Simmel showed the habit in 1944 with moving shapes. Thirty-four observers watched triangles and a disc move around a box. All but one described a social plot with a bully and victims. People read intention into motion. They do the same with behavior.
For study, link this axis to locus of control. That post explains how Rotter measured the expectancy that outcomes depend on you or on outside forces.
Jones and Davis and single acts
Edward Jones and Keith Davis published correspondent inference theory in 1965. It judges single acts. It asks when one act reveals a trait.
Three checks matter.
- Choice: the act was free, not forced by a role or order.
- Social desirability: the act broke a norm, so it says more about the person.
- Uncommon effects: the act had a result only that choice could give.
A soldier who follows an order tells you little. A volunteer who breaks ranks to help tells you more. A runner who finishes a marathon on a broken foot shows strong will because the pain should have stopped her.
Jones and Harris tested the rule in 1967 with the Castro essay. Readers read a pro-Castro or anti-Castro text. Some writers had chosen their side. Others had received their side from a coach. Readers still rated assigned pro-Castro writers as pro-Castro. Even a clear order did not remove the trait reading.
Use this model for one act only. It does not weigh repeated acts. That is Kelley.
Kelley and repeated acts
Harold Kelley published the covariation model in 1967. It judges repeated acts. It assigns the cause that moves with the act. The judge needs three kinds of data.
- Consensus: do others act the same way toward the same target.
- Distinctiveness: does this person act this way toward other targets.
- Consistency: does this person act this way toward this target each time.
| Pattern | Consensus | Distinctiveness | Consistency | Attribution |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Person | low | low | high | internal |
| Stimulus | high | high | high | external |
| Circumstance | low or high | low or high | low | outside both |
Take Tom and a comedian. Only Tom laughs, so consensus is low. Tom laughs at all comedians, so distinctiveness is low. Tom laughs at this comedian each time, so consistency is high. The pattern reads low, low, high. Attribute the laugh to Tom.
Change one fact. All people laugh, Tom laughs only at this comedian, and he does so each time. The pattern reads high, high, high. Attribute the laugh to the comedian.
Change consistency. Tom never laughed at this comedian before. Attribute this laugh to circumstance, such as mood or seating. Low consistency blocks both person and stimulus readings.
Leslie McArthur tested the model in 1972. People followed the rules when the data sat in front of them. Consistency weighed most. Distinctiveness weighed less. Consensus weighed least. Real judges neglect what others do. Keep this warning in mind on exams. Do not treat high consensus as strong evidence unless the item says it is salient.
Weiner and what happens after
Bernard Weiner added a third model in 1985. He kept internal and external locus. He added stability and controllability. The mix shapes feeling and effort after success or failure.
- Locus: is the cause inside or outside the person.
- Stability: will the cause last or change.
- Controllability: could the person steer it.
Stability sets expectancy. A stable cause says the result will repeat. Locus and control set feeling. Pride, guilt, shame and anger track who could steer what.
A failed exam shows the split. A hard paper is external, stable and uncontrollable, and it prompts anger. A headache on the day is internal, unstable and uncontrollable, and it prompts disappointment. Low ability is internal, stable and uncontrollable, and it prompts low expectancy. Low effort is internal, unstable and controllable, and it leaves a path back.
Weiner and Kukla showed the effort effect in 1970. High effort earned more reward after success. Low effort earned more blame after failure. Ability mattered less. Effort keeps hope because you can change it. Ability as a fixed trait does not.
The EBSCO research starter maps the four school causes the same way. Ability is internal, stable and uncontrollable. Effort is internal, unstable and controllable. Task difficulty is external, stable and uncontrollable. Luck is external, unstable and uncontrollable. Use this map as your default unless the item states otherwise.
Classroom work follows the map. Attribute failure to unstable controllable causes, such as wrong method or low effort on this test. Avoid stable uncontrollable readings, such as no talent. The same logic links to learned helplessness. That post explains the internal stable global pattern that predicts giving up.
Biases that bend the rules
The models describe ideal judges. Real judges use shortcuts. Four shortcuts appear on exams.
Fundamental attribution error over-reads traits in others. The actor stays salient. The setting stays in the ground. Gilbert described the fix as two steps: a fast trait reading, then a slow setting correction that people often skip.
Actor-observer difference splits the reading by role. Actors cite settings. Observers cite traits. Storms showed the camera angle moves the reading. When actors watched themselves on video, they used more trait terms.
Self-serving bias protects esteem. People credit success inside and push failure outside. A meta-analysis of 69 sport studies with 10,515 athletes found a moderate effect. Region, sex and level changed its size. Treat it as flexible, not fixed.
Culture changes the default. Many East Asian samples use more setting readings than American samples. Miller found the gap grows with age, so training matters. Priming an American or Chinese frame shifts bicultural judges. Expect a trait-first reading in American samples unless the item names another culture.
cognitive dissonance sits near this family as another consistency theory. Link it when the item mixes motive and attitude change. Do not merge it with attribution. One explains causes of acts. The other explains discomfort after acts.
How to sort any example
Exam items hide the model in one word. Ask what data the item gives you.
| Item gives | Model | Test question |
|---|---|---|
| One act, free or forced, normal or odd | Jones and Davis | Was the choice free and the act unexpected. |
| Many acts, what others do, what this person does elsewhere, what repeats | Kelley | Read consensus, distinctiveness, consistency in order. |
| Success or failure, then feeling or effort next time | Weiner | Name locus, stability and control, then predict expectancy. |
| Own success credited inside and others judged harshly | Bias | Name the shortcut and the direction of error. |
Write the three Kelley words as C-D-C. Write the three Weiner words as L-S-C. If the item lacks repeated data, do not use Kelley. If the item lacks an outcome with feeling, do not use Weiner.
How to study it
Save four cards as one list in Psychology World: Heider axis, Jones and Davis single acts, Kelley C-D-C, Weiner L-S-C. Add the Tom comedian case to the Kelley card. Add the failed exam case to the Weiner card. Drill the list with Flashcard, then with Question once the list holds four or more words, then with Typing. Daily-word notes bring the terms back before they fade.
Start from the dictionary at Psychology World when a term feels vague. Read the locus of control post for Rotter detail and the learned helplessness post for the giving-up pattern. Keep this post as the map. Use the linked posts for depth.
Frequently asked questions
What is attribution theory in simple words
Attribution theory is a set of rules for explaining why a behavior happened. It sorts causes into internal traits and external settings, then tests which fits the data.
What is the difference between internal and external attribution
Internal attribution points to the person, such as ability or effort. External attribution points to the setting, such as task difficulty or luck.
What are the three factors in Kelley covariation model
Consensus asks if others act the same way. Distinctiveness asks if this person acts this way elsewhere. Consistency asks if the act repeats with the same target.
What are Weiner three dimensions
Locus asks inside or outside. Stability asks lasting or brief. Controllability asks steerable or not. Stability sets expectancy. Locus and control shape feeling and effort.
How do you answer an AP Psychology attribution item
Name the data first. Single act points to Jones and Davis. Repeated data with C-D-C points to Kelley. Outcome with feeling points to Weiner. State the model, the pattern and the cause in that order.
Sources
- 1.Heider, F. (1958). The psychology of interpersonal relations.
- 2.Allen, M. S. et al. (2020). Systematic review and meta-analysis of self-serving attribution biases in the competitive context of organized sport. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 46(7).
- 3.EBSCO Research Starters (2019). Attribution Theory.
- 4.Wikipedia contributors. Attribution (psychology).
- 5.Albert Team. Attribution Theory: AP Psychology Review.