Psychology World — home
Blog

Maintenance vs elaborative rehearsal: the difference, and what repetition still does for memory

Maintenance rehearsal repeats information to hold it. Elaborative rehearsal links it to meaning. The difference, the 1973 studies and what each does for memory.

Cognition13 min read
By Psychology World

Maintenance rehearsal is the repetition of information to keep it in short-term memory. You repeat the words, but you do not think about their meaning. Elaborative rehearsal is different: you think about the meaning of new information and link it to things you already know. Maintenance rehearsal holds information for the moment. Elaborative rehearsal builds a memory that lasts.

If you repeat a phone number until you dial it, that is maintenance rehearsal. If you explain a new term with an example from your own life, that is elaborative rehearsal.

Most study guides stop there. The short version is correct, but it omits who made the distinction and what the experiments showed. It also omits a result that matters for exams. Repetition alone did not help people to recall words later, but it did help them to recognise the words.

  • Fergus Craik and Robert Lockhart made the distinction in 1972. They called the two activities Type I and Type II processing.
  • The words "maintenance" and "elaborative" come from a 1973 paper by Craik and Michael Watkins.
  • In that paper, six extra spoken rehearsals for each word did not increase later recall.
  • In a second 1973 paper, more rehearsal time increased later recognition, but not recall.
  • For study, elaborative rehearsal is the better of the two. But in a 2011 experiment, self-testing produced more learning than an elaborative study method.

The difference in one table

Maintenance rehearsal and elaborative rehearsal compared.
Maintenance rehearsalElaborative rehearsal
What you doRepeat the same words, aloud or silentlyThink about the meaning and link it to things you know
What it is forTo keep information available nowTo remember the information later
ExampleYou repeat a phone number until you dial itYou explain a new term with your own example
Name in Craik and Lockhart (1972)Type I processingType II processing
Other namesRote rehearsal, primary rehearsalSecondary rehearsal
Later recallNo increase in the 1973 experimentsHigher after deeper processing (Craik and Tulving, 1975)
Later recognitionIncreased with rehearsal time (Woodward and colleagues, 1973)Much higher after deeper processing (Craik and Tulving, 1975)

A quick memory aid: to maintain something is to keep it as it is. To elaborate is to add detail. Maintenance rehearsal keeps the information unchanged. Elaborative rehearsal adds meaning to it.

Where the two terms came from

In the 1960s, the leading models of memory gave rehearsal two functions. Craik and Watkins summarise the view of Waugh and Norman from 1965. In that view, rehearsal keeps items in a short-term store, and it also transfers information about them to a long-term store. Atkinson and Shiffrin agreed in 1968. Craik and Watkins quote them: "any information in short-term store is transferred to long-term store to some degree throughout its stay in the short-term store". If that is correct, a longer stay in short-term memory always gives a better long-term memory.

Some textbooks still give this simple version. The open textbook Psychology 2e from OpenStax says: "Rehearsal moves information from short-term memory to long-term memory."

In 1972, Craik and Lockhart disagreed. Their paper, "Levels of processing: A framework for memory research", separated two types of rehearsal. The first type only repeats work that the mind has already done:

This Type I processing, that is, repetition of analyses which have already been carried out, may be contrasted with Type II processing which involves deeper analysis of the stimulus. Only this second type of rehearsal should lead to improved memory performance.
— Craik and Lockhart, 1972

One year later, Craik and Watkins tested the idea. Their abstract gives the names that textbooks use today. It refers to the "maintenance" and "elaborative" aspects of rehearsal.

On the pages that follow in the same journal volume, Woodward, Bjork and Jongeward reported three related experiments. They suggested two other labels: primary rehearsal and secondary rehearsal. The APA Dictionary of Psychology adds a fourth name. It says that maintenance rehearsal is "also called rote rehearsal".

What Craik and Watkins found

Craik and Watkins did two experiments. The first experiment changed how long a word stayed in short-term memory. The second experiment changed how often the subjects rehearsed a word. Each experiment ended with a recall test that the subjects did not expect.

In the first experiment, 54 students listened to 27 lists of 21 words. Before each list, the students got a critical letter. Their task was to report the last word in the list that began with that letter. Thus each critical word stayed in mind until the next critical word replaced it.

Some words stayed for a moment, and some stayed while 12 other words passed. After all the lists, the students tried to recall as many words as possible. The number of words that passed while a word stayed in mind had no effect on this final recall.

In the second experiment, 16 students studied lists of 12 words and rehearsed aloud. The last four words were in capital letters, and the instructions said that these words were the most important. After some lists, the students rehearsed for 20 more seconds before recall. This delay added "an average of six extra rehearsals per word" for the last four words.

At the end, an unexpected test asked for all the words from all the lists. The extra rehearsals did not help. In the authors' words, "such maintenance rehearsal had no effect on later recall from the long-term store".

Their conclusion was careful: "It seems probable that it is the type of rehearsal rather than the amount of rehearsal which is critical for good long-term retention." They did not claim that repetition is always useless. They wrote that more rehearsal does help in some situations. In their view, it helps when people use the time to enrich the memory, not only to repeat the words.

What maintenance rehearsal still does

The abstract of the Craik and Watkins paper ends with a strong sentence: "Maintenance rehearsal does not lead to an improvement in memory performance." For one type of test, that sentence was too strong.

Woodward, Bjork and Jongeward showed words one at a time. After each word there was a blank period of 0 to 12 seconds, and the subjects kept the word in mind. Then a cue told them to remember the word or to forget it. A longer period gave more time for rehearsal.

The result had two parts. Recall was "essentially independent of amount of rehearsal". But "final recognition increased systematically with rehearsal".

Recall and recognition are different tests. In a recall test you produce the answer. In a recognition test you see the answer and identify it. A later review found the same pattern. Thalmann, Souza and Oberauer summarise a 1987 review by Greene. According to their summary, Greene concluded that spoken repetition, which they call articulatory rehearsal, "benefits recognition but not recall".

In 1994, Gardiner, Gawlik and Richardson-Klavehn examined recognition more closely. For each word that the subjects recognised, they gave one of two answers. "Remember" meant that recognition came with conscious recollection. "Know" meant that the word only felt familiar. The title of the paper gives the result: "Maintenance rehearsal affects knowing, not remembering; elaborative rehearsal affects remembering, not knowing."

For a student, this has a probable consequence. If you only repeat a definition, the term feels familiar. You can then recognise it in a multiple-choice question. But it is possible that you cannot write the definition from memory.

Why elaborative rehearsal works

The best-known evidence comes from Craik and Tulving in 1975. In ten experiments, subjects answered a question about each word. Some questions were about the letters: is the word in capital letters? Some were about the sound: does the word rhyme with "train"? Some were about the meaning: does the word fit in this sentence? After the questions, the subjects got a memory test that they did not expect.

In Experiment 2, the test was a recognition test. For words with the answer "yes", recognition "increased from 15% for case decisions to 81% for sentence decisions". The longer time for the meaning questions did not explain the result. In another experiment, a difficult task about the pattern of consonants and vowels took longer than an easy task about meaning. The easy task about meaning still gave better recognition. The authors concluded that "a minimal semantic analysis is more beneficial than an extensive structural analysis".

Craik and Tulving also questioned the word "depth". They wrote that "spread and elaboration may indeed be better descriptive terms" for their results. In their account, an elaborate memory uses the structure of your knowledge, and that structure helps you to find the memory again.

Here is the difference for one term. Suppose that you must learn "negative reinforcement". With maintenance rehearsal, you repeat the sentence "negative reinforcement removes an unpleasant stimulus" ten times.

With elaborative rehearsal, you ask questions about the sentence. What does "negative" mean here? What is an example? You take a tablet, the headache stops, and you take the tablet again the next time. How is this different from punishment?

Elaborative rehearsal can also include repetition. The OpenStax textbook has a section on ways to enhance memory. It says that elaborative rehearsal "involves both linking the information to knowledge already stored and repeating the information". The difference is what you do while you repeat.

Where the distinction is too simple

The two terms are useful, but the theory behind them has limits.

  • Depth is difficult to measure. A 2011 review by Ekuni, Vaz and Bueno reports an objection that Baddeley made in 1978. There is no independent method to measure how deep the processing is in an experiment.
  • The best type of processing depends on the test. The same review describes a 1977 study by Morris, Bransford and Franks. Processing of meaning gave better results when the test was about meaning. Processing of sound gave better results when the test was about rhymes.
  • Repetition is not always without effect. The review also reports experiments by Nelson from 1977, in which repetition at the level of sound did help memory.
  • The first function of maintenance rehearsal is also in doubt. In a 2019 review, Klaus Oberauer found that spoken rehearsal helped working memory in children, but not in adults. He wrote that rehearsal "might not play a causal role in keeping information in working memory".

There is also a practical limit. When you study, you rarely do only one type of rehearsal. Craik and Watkins wrote of a "maintaining" function and an "elaborating" function of the same activity. One minute of study can contain both.

Classifying exam scenarios

One question classifies most examples: does the person do anything new with the meaning of the information? If the person only repeats the same words, the answer is maintenance rehearsal. If the person adds an example, an image, a comparison or a link to old knowledge, the answer is elaborative rehearsal.

Common exam examples, classified with the question about meaning.
ExampleTypeWhy
You repeat a room number until you find the roomMaintenanceThe same words, and no new meaning
You repeat a verification code until you type itMaintenanceYou need the code only for a few seconds
You read one definition five timesMaintenanceYou repeat the words and add nothing
You write the definition in your own wordsElaborativeYou must process the meaning to change the words
You link "retroactive interference" to the day a new password made you forget the old oneElaborativeA link to your own experience
You compare a new term with a term that you already knowElaborativeA link to old knowledge
You ask why a statement is true, and you answer the questionElaborativeThe explanation adds meaning

An exam wants one label for each example. Real study time usually contains both types.

What this means when you learn psychology terms

To read a definition again is close to maintenance rehearsal. A 2013 review of ten study techniques by Dunlosky and colleagues rated rereading as low in utility. The review recommends practice tests in its place.

When you meet a new term, elaborate it first:

  1. 1.Write the definition in your own words.
  2. 2.Add one example from your own life.
  3. 3.Name one term that you confuse with it, and write the difference.

Then test yourself. Elaboration is not the end of the process. In 2011, Karpicke and Blunt compared self-testing with an elaborative study method, concept mapping. Self-testing produced more learning.

The Dunlosky review agrees: only practice testing and distributed practice got a high rating. A related technique, elaborative interrogation, got a moderate rating. Our guide to memorising psychology terminology shows how to plan the tests. Our article on spaced repetition explains why you must put time between them.

Use a test that makes you produce the answer. A multiple-choice question can feel easy because the term is familiar. That feeling is the "know" answer from the 1994 study.

Psychology World has the tests for the second step. You look up a term and save it to one of your own lists. Then you drill the list in one of three modes: flashcards, multiple-choice questions or typed answers. The multiple-choice mode needs a list of four or more terms. The study modes and the four steps of the learning loop are on the home page.

Frequently asked questions

Is maintenance rehearsal shallow processing?

In most cases, yes. Craik and Lockhart defined it as repetition of analyses that the mind has already done, at the same level. In practice that level is usually the sound of the words, which the levels-of-processing framework counts as shallow. Craik and Watkins give "a phonemic representation" as their example.

Does maintenance rehearsal move information into long-term memory?

Not reliably. In the 1973 experiments of Craik and Watkins, more time in short-term memory and more rehearsals did not increase later recall. But Woodward, Bjork and Jongeward found that later recognition increased with rehearsal time. Other experiments, such as those of Nelson in 1977, found that repetition can help. The safe conclusion is that maintenance rehearsal is a weak way to build a memory that you can recall.

What is an example of elaborative rehearsal?

You learn the term "cognitive dissonance". You do not repeat the definition. You think of a time when you acted against your own opinion and then changed the opinion. You also compare the term with a term that you know. Each link gives the memory more meaning.

Is elaborative rehearsal the same as deep processing?

The two ideas are close, but they are not the same. Depth refers to the type of processing, for example sound or meaning. Elaboration refers to how much you enrich the item and connect it to your knowledge. Craik and Tulving wrote in 1975 that elaboration may be a better description of their results than depth.

Is maintenance rehearsal an effective memory strategy?

It is effective for a short time. In the first experiment of Craik and Watkins, the subjects reported an average of 26.2 of 27 critical words correctly. Maintenance rehearsal is the correct choice for a number that you need for ten seconds. It is a weak strategy for an exam next month.

Are flashcards maintenance rehearsal or elaborative rehearsal?

That depends on how you use them. If you read the two sides of the card again and again, that is maintenance rehearsal. If you try to produce the answer before you turn the card, that is practice testing. If you add your own example to the card, that is elaborative rehearsal.

Sources

  1. 1.American Psychological Association (2018). Maintenance rehearsal. APA Dictionary of Psychology.
  2. 2.Craik, F. I. M., & Lockhart, R. S. (1972). Levels of processing: A framework for memory research. Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior, 11, 671–684.
  3. 3.Craik, F. I. M., & Watkins, M. J. (1973). The role of rehearsal in short-term memory. Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior, 12, 599–607.
  4. 4.Woodward, A. E., Bjork, R. A., & Jongeward, R. H. (1973). Recall and recognition as a function of primary rehearsal. Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior, 12, 608–617.
  5. 5.Craik, F. I. M., & Tulving, E. (1975). Depth of processing and the retention of words in episodic memory. Journal of Experimental Psychology: General, 104(3), 268–294.
  6. 6.Gardiner, J. M., Gawlik, B., & Richardson-Klavehn, A. (1994). Maintenance rehearsal affects knowing, not remembering; elaborative rehearsal affects remembering, not knowing. Psychonomic Bulletin & Review, 1(1), 107–110.
  7. 7.Thalmann, M., Souza, A. S., & Oberauer, K. (2019). Revisiting the attentional demands of rehearsal in working-memory tasks. Journal of Memory and Language, 105, 1–18.
  8. 8.Oberauer, K. (2019). Is rehearsal an effective maintenance strategy for working memory? Trends in Cognitive Sciences, 23(9), 798–809.
  9. 9.Ekuni, R., Vaz, L. J., & Bueno, O. F. A. (2011). Levels of processing: The evolution of a framework. Psychology & Neuroscience, 4(3).
  10. 10.Dunlosky, J., Rawson, K. A., Marsh, E. J., Nathan, M. J., & Willingham, D. T. (2013). Improving students' learning with effective learning techniques. Psychological Science in the Public Interest, 14(1), 4–58.
  11. 11.Karpicke, J. D., & Blunt, J. R. (2011). Retrieval practice produces more learning than elaborative studying with concept mapping. Science, 331(6018), 772–775.
  12. 12.Spielman, R. M., Jenkins, W. J., & Lovett, M. D. (2020). Psychology 2e, 8.1 How memory functions. OpenStax.
  13. 13.Spielman, R. M., Jenkins, W. J., & Lovett, M. D. (2020). Psychology 2e, 8.4 Ways to enhance memory. OpenStax.

Look the terms up yourself

18,000+ psychology and psychotherapy terms in English and German, on iPhone, iPad, Mac and Apple Vision.

See how Psychology World works
All posts